Originally posted September 17, 2026 by Matt Levy
Did you miss us? We missed you. August was nutso: 8–12-hour tour days, lots of them in a row, plus packing, packing, packing (BECAUSE I BOUGHT A HOUSE IN NYC!), a Bruce Springsteen tour en español (and I worked REAL hard to translate that content!) and moving into the new house. BUT WE'RE BACK, BAY-BEE. This month: cold-hot Mexican seafood, the most Italian Little Italy ever gets, and the 'hood that's prettier than SoHo, without the tourist crowds!
Something Awesome I Ate
Aguachile Negro, Mariscos El Submarino, Jackson Heights, Queens (more locations in Queens, Brooklyn and Jersey City). For decades, Mexican food in NYC meant food from the state of Puebla: tacos, tamales, cemitas, a legit mole if you were lucky. You know, "Mexican" food. But Mexico has 31 states, and as different communities emigrated north, they brought cuisines that weren't common before, even in NYC.
Enter aguachile, "chile water," from the northwestern state of Sinaloa. It's a raw seafood dish, traditionally shrimp, octopus or whitefish, tossed with lime juice, chiles and other vegetables and aromatics, and served immediately. This version is mixed seafood "cooked" with lime, chiles, soy sauce and a savory Maggi-type sauce.
When Mariscos El Submarino opened in 2020, New Yorkers used to Peruvian ceviche kinda went nuts. Here was hyper-regional Mexican cooking in a city known for its Mexican food, and best of all, it was spiiiiiccceeeyyyy. Wash it down con una cerveza o una michelada.
Something Amazing Happening This Month
100th Feast of San Gennaro, Little Italy, September 17–27. It's no surprise that New Yorkers (tour guides, locals, foodies, basically everybody) avoid Little Italy like we avoid Times Square. It's loud and hawkery, more than half Chinatown by now, and the Italian American food is less than authentic. (Ask us how we really feel!) But there's one time every year when Little Italy becomes the most Italian ever: the Feast of San Gennaro. And this year is the centennial!
Quick history bomb: Neapolitan immigrants who settled along Mulberry Street put up a small statue honoring their saint. Decades later it slowly (then quickly) turned into a mega-event lasting 11 days.
Most of the stands are kitschy, but there are decent eats among the 300+ vendors. Standouts include the charcoal-grilled pork braciole at Johnny Fasullo's stand and the fresh zeppole from Danny on the Corner. Go on a weekday between noon and 4 PM. That way you avoid the visitors from the fine state of NJ who overwhelm the festival Friday through Sunday.
Your New Favorite NYC Neighborhood
Tribeca, Manhattan. If you're already at San Gennaro and want to walk off the braciole and escape the crowds, get thee to Tribeca. The name stands for TRIangle BElow CAnal Street (it's actually more of a trapezoid). Its cast-iron district and stupendously beautiful historic industrial vibe are like SoHo minus the surging crowds of tourists lined up for Brandy Melville and the Museum of Ice Cream.
Expect lots of irregularly angled streets, Belgian paving blocks, and Victorian skyways connecting former office buildings now converted into lofts that sell for more zeros in a row than you've ever seen. At North Moore and Varick Streets you'll find Hook and Ladder Company 8, the fully functioning FDNY firehouse from all the Ghostbusters movies!! JFK Jr. famously lived here. The Cosmo was invented at Bobby De Niro's swanky nightlife spot, The Odeon. And my sister-in-law is a Tribeca native, which always sounds weird no matter how many times I say it.
Go wander around Tribeca, enjoying the beautiful buildings and iconic streetscapes. And drink a Cosmo. They're delicious.
No, really, walk off that braciole and drink a Cosmo.
— Matt Levy, Owner, Spread Love Tours